My list:
- Joe Dirt (somehow only got 9% positive reviews when it came out)
- Rat Race
- Scary Movie
- Not Another Teen Movie
Other than NATM (that was pretty bad, I just loved it cos I was a kid) I'm convinced that these movies did badly because most professional reviewers in the early 2000s grew up watching the silver screen. Joe Dirt remains a good movie, both from a comedy standpoint and from a storytelling standpoint. The twist actually made my heart ache for Joe and the unreliable narrorator bits are perfect.