What is your favorite movie that other people would find it unusual to be somebody's first pick or maybe not worthy? Mine is In Bruges. I definitely think that this movie deserves the praise but when I tell that to other people they usually say that there are better movies for the first place (like, you know the usual movies: Godfather, 12 Angry Men, Pulp Fiction, Shawshank Redemption etc..).I do think that those movies are amazing but In Bruges is for me the best, I don't know...
EDIT: I like how the comment section became long list of not so appreciated great movies..cool guys